Minority shareholders' derivative claim: director breached fiduciary duties
- John Deane
- Updated: Tue, 3rd Jan 2017
We brought a derivative claim for minority shareholders against a sole director who breached his fiduciary duty. We enabled the minority shareholders to:
- Hold the director accountable for his breach of fiduciary duty;
- Have the director return all monies received through his breach of duty;
- Remove the director from office;
- Disqualify the director for five years.
Following our successful action, we restructured the company to give:
- Minority shareholders the right to appoint a company director;
- Increased the shareholders’ control over board decisions.
Events leading to the derivative claim
Our clients are minority shareholders of a recruitment company operating in the natural resources sector. Its clients are UK and offshore energy providers. The director was an employee, but not a company shareholder.
Bringing a claim against the director
The director liaised with the company ‘s clients and placed candidates into roles. The company expected a commission fee for each role he filled. However, the director received commission fees from offshore clients, which didn’t appear in the company’s accounts. Over time, these commission fees amounted to a substantial figure.
The director was also a shareholder in a number of offshore clients. He masked his ownership using the nominee shareholder structure. Clearly the director acted in conflict, with no power to do so under the company’s articles.
The nature of a derivative claim
A consortium of minority shareholders sought our advice. We brought a derivative claim on behalf of the company against the director for his clear breach of duty. We included various third parties into the claim as defendants, since they assisted the director with his breach of duty.
Our arguments and the director’s defence
We proved to the court, at the permission stage, that:
The claim benefited the company
We first showed the benefit of pursuing the claims outweighed any risks or detriment to the company. If the breach of duty continued, the company would:
- Lose its reputation;
- Reduce referrers’ confidence in the company;
- Lose clients.
The claim was not personal
Other company members supported the claim. However, the majority did not want to pursue the director. Nevertheless, a minority did. We asked the court to take the view that the majority would consider the minority claim:
- To be for the company’s benefit;
- Not for a personal or other motive.
The directors’s defence
The director argued the offshore clients were his personal contacts, not the company’s contacts. Hence the benefit, i.e. the commission fees, did not accrue to the company.
The court’s view on the minority shareholders’ rights
The court held that the benefit did accrue to the company. The director received commission fees from onshore clients for which he accounted to the company. Therefore, the director had:
- Full knowledge and understanding of his role; and
- A duty to account to the company for fees received from certain offshore clients.
Protecting minority shareholders
Hence, the court:
- Awarded the company damages;
- Payable by the director to the company,
- That included the commission payments he had obtained.
- Removed the director from office; and
- His position as an employee.
- Granted the minority an indemnity for their costs,
- Paid by the company, once the company received the commission fees, i.e there was no direct loss to the company.
Understanding the practical issues
This case shows how derivative claims work in practice. If the director’s breach had become public knowledge, and the company had not taken action, the company would have lost clients and revenue.
Instead, our commercial experience, and appropriate legal arguments, recovered the profits that were lost due to the director’s breach of duty.
John Deane is a partner in the commercial team at Gannons. Derivative claims are complex in their nature, but with the right legal approach, can be successful. If action is not taken, then the damage can often be irreparable. Please do not hesitate to get in touch with John if we can assist.
We resolve disputes quickly and cost-effectively. We like to reduce your legal costs by presenting a strong case, and then settling, without going to court. Why not call or email me now to arrange an informal discussion.....