Commercial debts - high value
- John Deane
- Updated: Thu, 24th Nov 2016
When dealing with a debt, as with any dispute, you need to know what roads are open and how to avoid or minimise risk and costs – that is our expertise. When claiming a debt, we know the tactics to deploy to realise payment. We are equally able to defend disputed debts.
We specialise in enforcing and defending high value commercial debt claims. We act for a range of companies based in the UK and abroad. The expertise we offer is detailed knowledge of how to make the laws work to your advantage based on years of experience.
Our high value commercial debts service includes:
How to enforce the commercial debt
There are various means of dealing with high value commercial debts for corporates. We have set out some ideas together with important defences from a debtor’s perspective.
- We combine our legal and accountancy knowledge to ascertain the most timely and cost effective route of enforcing a debt payment with minimum hassle.
- We provide the full picture, and analyse other causes of action. For example, is an injunction to preserve assets suitable?
- We advise company creditors on the most appropriate method of obtaining payment and the advantages, disadvantages and risks associated with each method.
- There are a number of weapons available to bring a disputed or undisputed debt to a satisfactory conclusion.
Management of legal fees
A debt dispute will often end up before a judge. The courts now require a litigating party’s costs to be proportionate and reasonable. Proportionality is incurring costs that are relevant to the dispute, and necessary. As a boutique commercial law firm, we are able to manage your costs to fit with the requirements of the courts.
Corporate debtor’s insolvency
Where a debt is undisputed, a winding up petition can be presented on failure to pay once a statutory demand has been issued and left unpaid. The threat of this alone is often sufficient to persuade a reluctant debtor to pay. Alternatively, a creditor may serve a statutory demand which is a preparatory step to a winding up petition.
Using the statutory demand procedure
The statutory demand gives the corporate debtor three weeks to pay the debt. This excludes the day of service. The creditor cannot petition for the debtor company’s insolvency until the time period has lapsed.
Steps to take in the event of non-payment
Once the debtor company has failed to make payment within the time period, the creditor can petition for the debtor company to be wound-up on the grounds that it is unable to pay its debts.
Form and service of a statutory demand
The Insolvency Rules 1986 set out the form that a statutory demand must take. The statutory demand must be served at the debtor company’s registered office. The demand is usually personally served by the creditor’s solicitors. We can serve for you.
Handling the winding up process
Once the winding up petition has been presented, the petitioner will usually be required to advertise the petition in the London Gazette. That is done to ensure that other creditors of the debtor are made aware of the petition presented.
Claims from other creditors
For a creditor, it is always worth considering what impact a winding up will have on the debtor. From a creditor’s perspective, it will seek to ensure that it becomes entitled to the sums due. However, a creditor will not likely know how many other creditors an insolvent debtor may have.
Risks with a winding up
Once the winding up process has been initiated, other creditors will likely come forward. The majority of creditors will then have to agree on a suitable insolvency practitioner to handle the liquidation.
The claims of all creditors will have to be assessed by the insolvency practitioner handling the liquidation. The insolvency practitioner will also consider whether there are any claims against the directors for breach of duty, or fraudulent or wrongful trading.
The risk for an unsecured creditor is finding the debtor has secured creditors, and/or creditors with a greater claim for sums due from the debtor. We assess the risks and then advise accordingly.
Debts arising under foreign contracts
If the debt arises under a contract governed by the laws and jurisdiction of another country special issues can arise in terms of enforcing any debts due.
Serving a statutory demand from abroad on a company in the UK
Notwithstanding the terms of a contract, it is likely that if a company is resident in the UK, it may be served with statutory demands from overseas. The jurisdiction of the English courts extends to a company that:
- Has its registered office in England/Wales; or
- Has its centre of main interests in England/Wales.
However, care should be taken if there are a group of companies, with one of those group companies here in the UK. The “centre of main interests” may not be in the UK. In such a case, the courts would not have jurisdiction. We can advise on the international elements and path a route to resolution.
Serving a demand from the UK on a company abroad
For a company registered outside of the UK, the creditor company will have to show that the debtor company has its “centre of main interests” in England/Wales. The failure to comply with the rules can result in cost penalties. An objective viewpoint will provide clarity on these complex issues.
Defending corporate statutory demands
A corporate debtor can apply for an injunction to prevent the creditor from petitioning for the company’s winding up. This application must be made within the three weeks following service of the statutory demand. The ground for making the injunction application is usually that the debt is disputed and thus a winding up petition would be an abuse of process, because it should only be used for undisputed debts.
High value commercial debts and injunctions
Injunctions can also be granted on the grounds that the statutory demand was not properly served, or that it contained drafting errors. With this in mind, expert advice is required from both parties’ perspectives to ensure compliance with legal formalities.
Advantages and disadvantages of insolvency
Insolvency proceedings are public knowledge. Winding-up petitions are immediately searchable at the court and must be advertised before the hearing. Banks and credit reference agencies take note. The damage of a winding-up petition, even if not granted, can be substantial.
Impact of insolvency
This will affect any debtor’s ability to obtain credit in the future and will damage their business, often irreparably (because the bank’s immediate reaction will usually be to freeze the bank account). Insolvency proceedings also give the court power to stay any other proceedings against a debtor. Statutory demands will often cause a debtor to pay up.
Mediation and commercial settlement agreements
Mediation is a key tool in dispute resolution, particularly for claims relating to disputed debts. Mediation can take place at any time during the resolution process, before any court proceedings are issued or during those court proceedings.
What is mediation?
Mediation is consensual and parties are not obliged to mediate. However, following recent civil litigation reforms, mediation should always be considered prior to initiating court proceedings. Notably, a court will consider whether mediation had been considered when dealing with costs at the end of trial. The court may impose penalties on a party who unreasonably refused an offer to mediate before or during proceedings.
Why use mediation?
From a commercial perspective, there a number of advantages to mediation:
- Communication problems can be overcome, the mediator is a neutral third party.
- Business relationships can be preserved or enhanced by mediation, serving a statutory demand will do neither.
- Mediation is confidential.
- The process is flexible and can be tailored to meet parties’ needs.
- Mediation can provide a speedier resolution than court proceedings.
We are well experienced in the mediation process and can assist both debtors and creditors in preparation for mediation.
Debts that are disputed
With a disputed debt, the debtor challenges the creditor’s claim to the right to enforce the debt. It is important for a creditor to discuss the case at the outset with a solicitor who can advise on the documents to be preserved. Should an application to the court be necessary, disclosure will be inevitable and a creditor has a duty to preserve and produce documents relating to the disputed debt to support liability and ultimately, quantum. The debt may arise out of the terms of a business contract. In those circumstances, the debtor may allege that the term of the contract is void for operating as a penalty or otherwise. Thus, that debt is likely to be disputed.
Defending a disputed debt
There a number of tactics available to a defendant upon receipt of a claim for a disputed debt. The defendant may feel that the creditor has their own financial difficulties. If so, the defendant may in some circumstances be able to apply for an interim security for costs order which will require the creditor to place a sum of money into court to pay for the debtor’s legal costs should the creditor fail to succeed at trial.
Court application and summary judgment
Many apparently affluent debtors turn out to be in financial trouble when their creditors finally catch up with them. It is important for a creditor to bear this in mind when considering bringing a court application.
The debtor may not be able to meet a financial judgment. Our accountancy expertise gives us an advantage. We can interpret a debtor’s financial statements to ascertain potential cash flow problems and available assets for future post-judgment charging orders. We can also initiate enquiries into a debtor’s means which go beyond the published accounts.
Resolution of debt disputes
A court application may trigger a debtor’s payment. We advise creditors to make an application to the court together with an application for summary judgment where the creditor’s claim to the disputed debt is sufficiently strong. Debtors should be cautious of summary judgment applications. A creditor’s costs can escalate and debtors can be faced with a creditor’s legal bill in conjunction with the disputed debt.
Using a court application, a creditor can claim for interest on the disputed debt from the alleged date of payment up until the date of judgment.
In appropriate cases, a creditor can use a freezing injunction to preserve the debtor’s assets pending a court judgment. If the creditor obtains such an injunction, the creditor can also obtain an order for the disclosure of the debtor’s assets. An advantage of this is that the creditor has an idea of the debtor’s financial means at a very early stage of proceedings.
Showing risk with a freezing injunction application
The creditor must prove to the court that there is a real risk of the debtor’s assets being dissipated. Evidence is crucial and we can advise on the appropriate documents to succeed on an application for a freezing injunction. The courts have set a particularly high burden for creditors to prove.
The debtor will have to produce evidence about their assets or risk being in contempt of court. From a debtor’s perspective, this is highly detrimental as the court will often order that the debtor cannot take its assets below a particular level. With this in mind, freezing injunctions often trigger a debtor’s payment of the disputed debt as the administrative costs of complying with a freezing injunction are notoriously high.
Our high value commercial debt track record
Recent instructions include acting for:
- A national materials supplier on claiming unpaid invoices from contractors on the brink of insolvency.
- A leading supplier of IT and software solutions on claiming the payment of disputed debts with interest.
- A regional property development company on resisting claims for alleged unpaid and disputed debts resulting in the dismissal of the claimant’s claims.
- A UK electronics manufacturer on the payment of its invoices from customers on fixed credit using an application for summary judgment.
Get in touch with us for advice on any aspect of a high value commercial debt, whether disputed or undisputed. This is a complicated area, as is apparent above, and legal advice is recommended, particularly as there are different options available to creditors with inherent timescales for compliance.
We recover high value commercial debt. We tell you the tactics to achieve a successful outcome. Our solution depends on the debt's value. Why not call or email me to arrange an informal discussion.